Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: UFC 143 Results: Winners, Losers, And Other Thoughts

Want a professional league? Be professional.

Perhaps Major League Soccer still hasn't quite caught on in the states not due to competition from American football or the overlap with baseball season, but because it is so bloody difficult to comprehend all the rules of the league?

It certainly doesn't help that MLS runs a frighteningly amateur website, so that when fans try to find information about how the league is run, they first need to scour the site for the 'about' section, and then come to realize that it hasn't been updated in over a year.

Star-divide

In addition to not having enough smarts to place Philadelphia in the eastern conference, nor to realize that they have listed Fredy Montero twice within a list of 15 players, they consistently refer to the "designated player"--but they never define what this might mean. Wait, I've found it now, four clicks away.

Of course, this might not matter to the casual fan, who simply wants to choose a team and then heap praise or rain insults upon their heads, but to those who wish to be able to discuss the composition of a team, their acquisitions, their player development, and their abilities in relation to other teams in the MLS, understanding the league matters a great deal.

Last season, I was a 'casual' Sounders fan, if that can be used to describe one with a stack of rave green in her closet who proudly sings songs about shooting. This season, however, I've been doing my best to follow the drama over the player negotiations and to read about recent player signings (this is slightly hampered by the inability most MLS writers to, y'know, write, and yes I will call you out on your inaccuracies as well as your grammar). But in order to get excited about a new signing, you first have to know where he fits into the structure of the league.

For instance, yesterday the Sounders signed Blaise Nkufo, the Swiss international currently playing for Dutch side FC Twente. Rather than simply checking out his stats and wondering where he will fit in Sigi's arrow, it's necessary to start looking at "international slots". Our 8 are filled, according to some, but when you consider the definition of "international" (is Cuban defector Osvaldo Alonso really an international, for instance?) and then thinking about how we can trade international slots with other MLS teams (for what, cash and prizes?) well, the head starts to spin. Add to that the fact that Nkufo might also be a designated player, taking one of those two allocations, and there is nothing as simple as just being thrilled over the acquisition of a genuinely decent player who might teach Fredy a trick or two.

And, obviously, the website's 13 methods of player acquisition do not illuminate the subtleties that occur with internationals, DPs, and bringing players in during the July window. However, they let us know Lando is the only grandfathered DP! My knowledge abounds! (er, no, that was 2009. Sorry.)

There are many, many things that MLS could do to help the league find greater support. I'm extremely fortunate to live in the city with the best fans, but if the league folds, Seattle goes with it. While fixing the CBA/free-agent issue seems as though it would take precedence in keeping MLS alive, it would likely be much simpler just to update the website while we're waiting for more negotiations. Sometimes it's the littlest things that keep fans from becoming frustrated and deciding to seek solace in March Madness rather than sticking with MLS.

Comment 2 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Haha! I think it’s probably because the more people learn about about MLS structure, the more angry they get. But to try to answer a few questions— no Alonso doesn’t count as international. Political asylum is as good as a green card to MLS, so we have 7 now — Zakuani, Hurtado, Montero, Gonzalez, Nyassi, Ljungberg and Nkufo. Additionally, we’re about to sign an 18-year old Argentine striker Miguel MontaƱo who will be our 8th intl.

I think Nkufo will not be a DP yet. His salary is $550k, but by playing only half a season, his contribution to our cap is only $275k (Beckham only counts $200k against LA’s cap because of the AC Milan deal). What we do next season is big mystery, but a lot of the speculation is that we pay for Nkufo by leaving Jaqua (and his $200k salary) exposed in the expansion draft next year.

If you want even more head-scratching, recall the recent deal where Luis Gil signed with MLS on the condition that he play for either Seattle or RSL.. MLS held a weighted lottery that was won by KC, and Gil was then traded to RSL for a 2nd round draft pick an intl slot, and 25% of his transfer fee. But NOW, we have Ellis McLoughlin coming to MLS by way of Hertha, and he only wants to play for Seattle. But he has to come into the league by allocation order instead of lottery (as a “returning national team player” even though he never played above the U-20s)… So we have to trade up the allocation order list to acquire him.

When it comes to MLS, the more you know, the less you understand. Oh, and don’t even mention Donovan’s new deal with the Galaxy to any crusty old MLS fans… They’ll just start seething and shivering and clawing their faces. His grandfathering was only supposed to last a year, but then it was extended two more years with the expectation that it would expire and Galaxy would trade for a DP slot for him. But they didn’t, they just signed him to a brand new shiny monster contract instead.

Pssst… MLS doesn’t actually have rules. The “rules” are just a joke they play on newcoming fans to trick people into thinking there’s an order to the chaos and magic of league parity.

Cheers!

by Ajas on Mar 5, 2010 8:41 PM GMT reply actions  

This is what kills the league for a lot of people; you can’t take it seriously because of this nonsense. You have a structure designed to give each team an equal shot at incoming players (who are presumed to have no preferences), so if they only want to go to one team, the league puts its thumb on the scale but still acts within its own processes/structures. This makes the structures look corrupt, and the league look incompetent. Ridiculous.

I’m reminded why I found the league sort of laughable before Seattle got a team. They need to start transitioning the league away from its current format (and yeah, I know this is part of the reason for the CBA impasse). I understand why they did it this way, the specter of the NASL and all that, but it’s time to at least have a plan for removing the training wheels.

by marc w. on Mar 7, 2010 8:06 AM GMT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

We discuss English football from a North American perspective. Sometimes we call it soccer, sometimes, football--we don't care too much. What matters is that we're Villa til we...cry

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

051_small
Fabian Delph's return to Leeds: Part 2
051_small
Fabian Delph's return to Leeds United: Part 1
Bread_press_small
Crests, Logos, and Creepy Animals

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Obsessives.

Trident_small Kirsten Schlewitz

Avatar_small Aaron Campeau

Villa_gnome_small Robert Lintott

250676_220147481342225_100000409258349_857781_5315262_n_small Andrew Cieslak

28300_581179385260_56905363_33756207_5291270_n_small Gareth Simpson

Bread_press_small MattF15