Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The MMA (After) Hour

Aston Villa Set to Clean House: Sidwell, Carew, Davies Join List of Players Set to Leave

Aston Villa manager Gerard Houllier ponders the party he will throw once he's sold Steve Sidwell to West Ham (Photo by Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)


According to Stuart James' latest this could be an interesting six months for Aston Villa, with Steve Sidwell, John Carew, Curtis Davies, Richard Dunne, Stephen Ireland, Stephen Warnock, Brad Friedel, Nigel Reo-Coker and Habib Beye all possibly on the outs at Villa. James lends further credence to the Sidwell to West Ham theory which has gained traction in the tabloids in recent days but now has some a bit more legitimacy to it. From the tone of James' piece it would also not come as much of a shock if Davies and/or Beye are gone by February with the rest to follow in the summer.

The two big surprises are Nigel Reo-Coker and (to a lesser extent) Stephen Warnock. Reo-Coker is out of contract at the end of this season and were he to leave Villa he would do so on a free which seems something of an undervaluing of the midfielder who has (when healthy) been one of Villa's best players on the year. Warnock has seen his form dip over the past six months or so and has been something of a liability for Villa on occasion this year but he's still fairly young and not far removed from the quality that led to his being named to England's World Cup squad over the summer. Both players are clearly somewhat attractive and likely have something to offer a lot of teams, but Villa seem determined to move in a different, more youthful direction and it might be best for all involved for the two to move on.

Star-divide

Something else worth drawing attention to:

The club are looking to change their recruitment strategy and will seek to target promising young talent as opposed to experienced players in the twilight of their career who come with big wage demands and have no sell-on fee. For that reason Villa have no interest in signing Robbie Keane from Tottenham Hotspur despite continued speculation.

That's noteworthy for a couple of reasons. Primarily, if this is in fact Villa's strategy going forward it is something of a departure from what we saw under Martin O'Neill (although it wouldn't be especially reasonable to call Ashley Young, James Milner, Fabian Delph and Stewart Downing "experienced players in the twilight of their career" at the time MON brought them into the club.) Less importantly (mainly because no one will listen) is James' scuttling of the Keane to Villa talk. For all of his faults, Stuart James is more well informed of the intentions of Villa where the transfer market is concerned than most other journalists, and the certainty of his tone seems to imply a certainty about his belief that Keane will not end up in claret and blue any time in the near future.

Many of us have had suspicions about where the club was headed in regards to their transfer strategy under Gerard Houllier and while this piece certainly does not serve to confirm them it does lend them a bit more credence. There's not really any reason to doubt the veracity of these claims and increasing reason to believe them. The funds coming in from the sale of these players will not allow for a Manchester City-esque shopping spree, but speculation has long been that the issue is less a scarcity of funds to spend on transfer fees and more a bloated wage budget. If that is in fact the case and these moves do happen, we could be in for a very interesting summer indeed.

Comment 7 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

What shocked me about this article more than anything was the total lack of sourcing here

We have no idea who told James any of this, and that just blows my mind that it’s acceptable journalism. Usually you at least get “sources at the club” or something like that.

Instead, we get “It is understood…” Understood by whom, Stuart? Your pet unicorn in your mind and his friend Mr. Wiggens, the Vole?

by Robert Lintott on Dec 22, 2010 6:15 AM GMT reply actions  

I'm ok with this.

Just like I’m ok as long as Houllier’s training methods don’t piss off Stewie or Ash. We’ve already signed all the young’ins to new contracts (I think all, unless I missed one. All of the ones that have seen the pitch for the first team this season, anyway). That, to me, is the best reflection of where this team is going, and one I can get behind.

But as much as I haven’t been happy with Warnock this season, I can’t see him go at the moment, unless number one on Houllier’s list is a left-back. Maybe he’s just upset that he won’t move to Birmingham? Also, why is L Young not on this list?

by Kirsten Schlewitz on Dec 22, 2010 1:43 PM GMT reply actions  

I'm in love with that young LB at CSKA Moscow... Not that this has anything to do with anything, but I'd throw an infant off a bridge to get him in here to replace stupid Warnock.

Overall though I agree.

Seems silly to think we can jettison all these guys and just replace them lickety-split.

Methinks a lot of this shit’s gonna have to wait for Summer.

The 40 trumps all!
"WHY IS LIAM POPPINS STICKING. IT'S AN ABSURDLY BAD NICKNAME"
-LiamP(oppins)

by thedirkatron on Dec 22, 2010 4:02 PM GMT up reply actions  

So is Brad Guzan considered some sort of wild mountain douche or something?

He doesn’t even seem to merit a mention in any of the “Brad Friedel is old and gonna be gone” stories…

The 40 trumps all!
"WHY IS LIAM POPPINS STICKING. IT'S AN ABSURDLY BAD NICKNAME"
-LiamP(oppins)

by thedirkatron on Dec 22, 2010 3:55 PM GMT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

We discuss English football from a North American perspective. Sometimes we call it soccer, sometimes, football--we don't care too much. What matters is that we're Villa til we...cry

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

1_small
Villa @ Portland
Tf_reasonably_small_small
An Idea

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Obsessives.

Trident_small Kirsten Schlewitz

Avatar_small Aaron Campeau

Villa_gnome_small Robert Lintott

Sidebeard_small Andrew Cieslak

28300_581179385260_56905363_33756207_5291270_n_small Gareth Simpson

Bread_press_small MattF15