Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Relegation Simulation: Rewriting College Football History

An Aston Villa January Transfer Window Wish List: What's Yours?

It's somehow nearly December, meaning always-present transfer speculation will soon kick into overdrive. Given the club's ongoing austerity drive it's tough to imagine Aston Villa will be doing a whole lot during the window, but A) Randy Lerner is a very rich man, he's shown a willingness to spend money if things look bad, December is terrifying and B) a boy can dream, right? There are some pretty obvious issues with this squad and there are only two periods of time per year during which they can be addressed. And this is a wish list, after all; I don't know about the letters you sent to Santa when you were a kid, but in my world the jolly man wasn't working under budgetary constraints.

So, after the jump are some lists I've put together about what I'd like to see Villa do in January. Despite the fact that one of the lists is dedicated to things I know damn well won't happen, I'm working under a constraint of plausibility. That's why there's no list that consists of 100 bullets, all of them followed by the words "Buy Hulk." Have you got any fantasies for the post-holiday shopping season? I know you do. Feel free to share them in the comments.

Star-divide

Could Happen

  • Added depth at outside back. Enda Stevens will help, but he's not enough to give me a sense of real comfort. Eric Lichaj can cover both sides (and would probably be an upgrade on both sides) but he'll take a while to get back to game speed. If Warnock or Hutton goes out for an extended period, it could get scary. Or scarier than it already is.
  •  Stephen Ireland goes away, permanently this time. He's not playing, he makes a ton of money and he's got to have value to someone. Contracts like his are what makes it difficult for Villa to add players that could actually be beneficial. I still think he can be a useful player somewhere, but it won't happen at Villa.
  • A new home for Brad Guzan. This one is selfish; it doesn't really help Villa (though he'd likely bring in a little bit of a transfer fee, which is nice) but as a USMNT fan it's tough watching his development slowed by sitting on the bench. Given is tremendous and isn't showing signs of slowing down; it's time for Little Brad to go somewhere else.
  • Assuming the above goes through, we'll need a new backup keeper. Someone like David James (not actually David James, just someone competent, cheap and too old to be upset about a lack of playing time) would suffice.

Probably Won't Happen

  • One of Richard Dunne/James Collins/Stephen Warnock going away. Dunne has been good this season, but Ciaran Clark is the future and he's not getting time. Collins has been bad, but likely has more value that Dunne just by virtue of his age. Warnock has been mediocre, has no real value and is the only left back on the team, but he annoys me. They all make a lot of money.
  • Enda Stevens loaned back to Shamrock Rovers for the remainder of the season. What little I've seen of Stevens, I like. But he's not a Premier League player just yet, and he needs to get as much experience as possible. Loaning him to an English lower-level or Scottish club would be even better.
  • Add another wide midfielder for depth. Preferably someone like Robert Pires in terms of stage of career/cost without the unfortunate shorts length and personality of Robert Pires. I like N'Zogbia and think he'll end up being a good addition, but behind him we have Marc Albrighton (who is, let's remember, no longer amongst the living) and uh. So this is an area I would like to see shored up.

Will Never Happen In A Million Years But I Wish It Would

  • Recall Jean Makoun from Olympiakos. THIS WOULD SOLVE LIKE EIGHT DIFFERENT PROBLEMS.
  • Sell Alan Hutton. Give him away if need be. Have Marc Albrighton play right back for all I care, just make him go away.
  • Sell Darren Bent. This one will be controversial, I know. Bent was a large part of what saved Villa's season last year, and as far as pure poachers go there aren't many in the world that are better. But on this team, he's wasted. Gabby Agbonlahor is in the form of his life, Nathan Delfouneso is knocking on the door and Emile Heskey wouldn't actually be a complete disaster if he was actually playing striker rather than wide midfield. There are other areas in need of serious upgrade, and the sale of Bent could help fund them; as a regular choice for the England squad, he's probably more valuable now than he was when he was brought in, and there's no way he's happy with the service he's receiving from his teammates. Sell Bent and use the money elsewhere and there's a good chance you end up with a better team. (And note: unless all of the money from a sale of Bent is available for re-investment, I don't advocate doing so.)
  • Buy Markus Henriksen. I saw a rumor farm make a connection between Villa and the 19-year-old Rosenborg midfielder, and I have never wished more urgently to be able to suppress my skepticism. He's young and raw and might not make an immediate impact, but he's going to be a very special player and soon the big clubs will be crawling all over him. Best to beat them to the punch.

Comment 16 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

You forgot

Check out Tottenham’s reserves/injured list and buy some of those losers.

by Andrew Cieslak on Nov 28, 2011 10:05 PM GMT reply actions  

What about?

The fact that Gabby has been a bit on the brittle side? If you sell off DBent you’re at risk of being striker-less over the periods of the season that Gabby might miss. Heskey is a competent reserve but he’s never been a big enough goal-scorer (in terms of number of goals, he’s plenty large as a human being) to lead the line if DBent were transferred and Gabby injured.

Cheers – Neal

by Neal Thurman on Nov 28, 2011 10:44 PM GMT reply actions  

A fair point.

You’ve still got Delfouneso, Heskey and Weimann there, but if they were to sell Bent adding another striker might not be the worst idea.

by Aaron Campeau on Nov 28, 2011 10:46 PM GMT up reply actions  

What would you buy?

If you were to sell DBent? Are there players that are likely available that you’d buy for the 20 or so million Bent would likely bring back?

www.NeverManageAlone.com

by Neal Thurman on Nov 28, 2011 10:48 PM GMT up reply actions  

Not sure I have any specific names in mind.

I know a new winger would be huge; N’Zogbia I like but Albrighton I have lost a lot of faith in, and I’m not the only one. A new and younger central defender, to act as a future plan in concert with Clark, would be huge.

If I’m going to throw names out there; Douglas would make me absolutely giddy, though I suspect he’s aiming quite a bit too high. I like Matt Jarvis quite a bit and think he’d fit well in McLeish’s system. I’m not going to bother with strikers because dear heavens are there a lot of serviceable cheap strikers, but a better version of Emile Heskey seems about right.

by Aaron Campeau on Nov 29, 2011 1:59 AM GMT up reply actions  

Douglas as in Costa?

That’ll just remind me of the hilarious rumours in the summer about Sergio Canales and Diego.

I’d be okay with Matt Jarvis but he’s just…uninteresting. Though that’s probably as far as it’ll get with McLeish.

i tell the truth; i lie a lot

by jonthefon on Nov 29, 2011 2:38 AM GMT up reply actions  

Nah, Douglas the centerback from Twente.

Jarvis is definitely uninteresting but like you said, with McLeish that’s about what I think can be expected.

by Aaron Campeau on Nov 29, 2011 4:01 AM GMT via mobile up reply actions  

Since I play a ton of football manager

I would be happy, the way this team is now, to sell Bent and replace him with a striker from France. Say, Moussa Sow or Hoarau. They would cost a fraction of what Bent does.

Another good solution would be to start watching more Ligue 1 since all these players I’m currently enamored with play there.

by Andrew Cieslak on Nov 29, 2011 2:59 PM GMT up reply actions  

Change the club's name to Aston Messi.

"in order that you will write correctly of wat you really see if you dint go around with your eyes shut"
Cricket blog?

by MattF15 on Nov 28, 2011 11:06 PM GMT reply actions   1 recs

We need an effective RM

I’d love Dempsey to come here, I feel he is exactly what we need. Plus I agree with Guzan needing to move but I don’t feel he needs replacement. Young benji is fucking superb

by Brian Bonilla on Nov 29, 2011 5:50 PM GMT reply actions  

NEYMAR

I wish

Villa 'til i die!

by jgrimse on Nov 30, 2011 9:50 PM GMT via iPhone app reply actions  

Addition by subtraction

Dump Heskey and give Fonz or Weimann playing time up front. That old clod is hindering our player development!

by RipCityVillan on Dec 1, 2011 3:16 PM GMT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

We discuss English football from a North American perspective. Sometimes we call it soccer, sometimes, football--we don't care too much. What matters is that we're Villa til we...cry

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

1_small
Villa @ Portland
Tf_reasonably_small_small
An Idea

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Obsessives.

Trident_small Kirsten Schlewitz

Avatar_small Aaron Campeau

Villa_gnome_small Robert Lintott

Sidebeard_small Andrew Cieslak

28300_581179385260_56905363_33756207_5291270_n_small Gareth Simpson

Bread_press_small MattF15